As sleep-deprived college students, we all know what it’s like to need a caffeine boost before you can function, or maybe you just need that little pick-me-up after you walk out of class knowing you bombed that exam. As the third largest city in Indiana, Evansville has no shortage of coffee shops, and each one has something special to make it stand out from the crowd. Here are my top three recommendations as an Evansville local (just in case you’ve already sampled the entire menu at Honey Moon):
Located in beautiful downtown Evansville, Penny Lane Coffeehouse has a funky classic-rock vibe that is great for hanging out or getting homework done. They have a variety of drinks, from specialty lattes to smoothies to teas. Lunch and breakfast options are also available, and nearly everything on the menu has some kind of callback to seventies-inspired pop culture – Penny Lane itself is named after Kate Hudson’s character in the 2000 film Almost Famous. The tabletops are decoupaged with classic rock icons, movie posters, and retro stickers, immersing you in the cozy yet inspiring atmosphere. Penny Lane also offers a selection of items from local artists, with a rotating collection of both art and handmade goods such as jewelry. Whether you’re looking for somewhere to catch up over breakfast or somewhere to grab a last-minute birthday present for that friend who has everything, Penny Lane has you covered.
MY REC: Iced Voodoo Child & the Breakfast Club!
Aptly named for its proximity to the Ohio, River City Coffee + Goods is a quaint little shop located on Main Street. They have a unique menu of experimental drinks, such as the “Hoosier Brew,” a cold brew drink made with corn and sweet milk (that tastes surprisingly chocolatey), that allows you to step outside of your comfort zone. If you’re not feeling so adventurous, their delicious house-made syrups dress up even the most basic menu items. River City also offers a great selection of local handiworks and merchandise to show your Evansville pride, including t-shirts, postcards, buttons, and flags, just to name a few. If you consider yourself a crafty person, you might consider visiting their sister store – a few doors down, you’ll find Memo, a stationery store filled to the brim with beautiful cards, witty stickers, and more pens than you can count.
MY REC: Iced Latte w/ house-made caramel syrup & any kind of baked good!
Okay, so Washington Square Mall might not be as dead as you thought. A bit of a hidden gem, Mission Grounds is located just inside, boasting a great punch card system where you can get a free drink after purchasing five. (And trust me – you’ll speed through that card in no time). The baristas are always happy to give you recommendations, even offering the “Faith,” a menu item that gives you the opportunity to let them decide. Their rotating seasonal menu, featuring delicious house specialties like the Tiramisu Cold Brew in the summer or the Caramel Apple Chai in the fall, is what truly sets it apart from the crowd. Consider grabbing a drink and a quick bite before heading over to the Evansville Rescue Mission thrift store. It’s a great stop for lazy Saturday mornings and after-class detoxes alike.
MY REC: Any seasonal drink & a banana chocolate chip bundt muffin!
CRESCENT MAGAZINE © 2024
